Smiths Falls Case Study
The history of David Leonardo’s coverage of local politics in Quebec raises a reasonable question: have similar practices appeared in the Ontario papers associated with him? In a 2017 Quebec Superior Court judgment, Justice Marie-Claude Armstrong wrote:
“Coverage of municipal affairs was not handled in a balanced, measured, or accurate manner.”
— Paragraph 278, 2017 QCCS 1104
English translation; concerning the Quebec coverage examined in that case
That finding concerned Quebec coverage; it was not a finding about the Ontario papers. These issues are provided for independent review. The sample does not establish why editorial decisions were made.
What this sample shows
Valley Journalism Project’s assessment
Across these ten issues, the record shows a clear disparity in the form, prominence and framing of coverage of Nate Morris, Christopher Cummings and Peter McKenna.
The project’s assessment is that coverage of Morris’s water-quality concerns was broadly dismissive. This exchange provides a primary-source record of the concerns he explained to Leonardo, his correction that he had not claimed the MECP took no action, and his repeated offers to provide supporting documents. Readers can compare the correspondence with the selected coverage in the issues below.
“I am thinking of skipping this story because, although important, it is above the voters' heads. Perhaps it would be best to present the positive; the future you can give Smiths Falls.”
Valley Journalism Project’s assessment
The project considers this remark dismissive of readers’ ability to engage with a complex local issue. Leonardo calls the story “important,” then says it is “above the voters' heads.”
Redacted copy of the original six-page Outlook email thread; email addresses have been removed. Message content, dates and sequence are preserved.
Candidate coverage: October 7
For example, the October 7 issue published separate candidate profiles headed “McKenna campaigns on experience, planning and our community-first” (print page 10; combined PDF page 130) and “Cummings pitches experience, financial background as asset” (print page 11; combined PDF page 131). Morris was named as a competing candidate but did not receive a separate profile in the selected coverage of that issue.
September 30: the million-dollar article
The September 30 issue gave prominent front-page placement to “Electing Morris could cost town a million dollars” (front page; combined PDF page 101). On page 3, the article was headed “Potential damages from CAO” and “Electing Nathaniel Morris could cost the Town a million dollars” (combined PDF page 103).
The million-dollar figure was a conditional estimate about possible future costs, not a court award or an established liability. The article said a dismissal “if pronounced as an unjust dismissal by a court could cost the Town up to $500,000” and that malicious prosecution “in the extreme would reach an additional $550,000.” It also said the amount would depend on the CAO’s employment agreement and the circumstances of any dismissal, and that legal fees were unknown.
The article did report that Morris had released a report about environmental test results and summarized the allegation that the information had not been promptly shared. It also reported that the CAO rejected the allegations. But it did not reproduce the underlying evidence or present Morris’s stated case for a for-cause dismissal in comparable detail to its discussion of possible damages, severance, legal expenses and recruitment costs. This imbalance is the basis for the project’s assessment that the article’s presentation was one-sided.
October 21: the newspaper’s characterization
The October 21 Morris profile stated: “Many in social media, not just opponents, are calling this a personal vendetta.” It did not identify the people making that claim or link to the social-media comments. This quotation is the newspaper’s characterization; the project does not present it as an established fact.
Town advertising in the sample
Eight of the ten issues contain a full-page Town of Smiths Falls advertisement. The pages include public notices and election information, along with service updates, program announcements and event promotions. The project’s review found that the vast majority of the space was discretionary municipal content. The two Veterans Way street-renaming notices were required to appear in a local newspaper, but neither notice had to occupy a full page. Election law required certain voting information but did not prescribe newspaper publication.
The two issues without a full-page Town advertisement were September 30 and October 21. Both contain particularly conspicuous Morris-focused negative framing: the September 30 front-page headline “Electing Morris could cost town a million dollars” and the October 21 Morris-profile headline “Morris campaigns on accountability, affordability and a dismissal of CAO”, preceded by “Will use Strong Mayor Powers.”
This overlap in the ten-issue sample is noteworthy and merits independent examination. It does not establish coordination between municipal leadership and the paper, or that advertising influenced editorial coverage. The September 16 issue also contains the Morris-related display lines “But province says water safe” and “Mayoralty candidate questions water quality” (print page 2; combined PDF page 82), while that issue contains full-page Town content. Not all critical Morris coverage occurred in issues without Town advertisements.
The complete issues are provided so readers can examine the reporting and municipal material in context and reach their own conclusions.
The Sample
The sample consists of ten complete issues of the Smiths Falls Record-Journal dated August 19 through October 28, 2026. They span the 2026 municipal-election campaign and include the October 28 election-results issue. The combined PDF contains the full issues; the headlines and page references below identify selected election-related coverage within them.
Combined PDF: ten full issues, August–October 2026
This file contains the complete issues in which the sampled articles appeared (200 pages, about 40 MB). It is not limited to the ten articles.
Issue 1 of 10
August 19, 2026
- Coverage format
- Shared candidate comparison
- Candidates named
- Nate Morris; Christopher Cummings
Article headline
“Smiths Falls election taking shape as nomination deadline approaches”
Print page 3 · Combined PDF page 3- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- Yes
Issue 2 of 10
August 26, 2026
- Coverage format
- Shared candidate comparison
- Candidates named
- Nate Morris; Christopher G. Cummings; Peter McKenna
Front-page headline
“Mayoral race has 3 candidates & 15 for councillor”
Print page 1 · Combined PDF page 21- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- Yes
Issue 3 of 10
September 2, 2026
- Coverage format
- Candidate announcement
- Candidate named
- Peter McKenna
- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- Yes
Issue 4 of 10
September 9, 2026
- Coverage format
- Candidate announcement; repeated story
- Candidate named
- Peter McKenna
The same headline and opening text appear in the September 2 issue.
- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- Yes
Issue 5 of 10
September 16, 2026
- Coverage format
- Candidate-focused story; shared candidate comparison
- Candidates named
- Nate Morris; Christopher G. Cummings; Peter McKenna
Story A — candidate-focused story about Nate Morris
Secondary display line
“Mayoralty candidate questions water quality”
Print page 2 · Combined PDF page 82Story B — shared candidate comparison
Front-page headline
“Three mayoralty candidates offer competing visions”
Print page 1 · Combined PDF page 81Article headline
“3 candidates offer competing visions for Smiths Falls mayor’s chair”
Print page 9 · Combined PDF page 89- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- Yes
Issue 6 of 10
September 30, 2026
- Coverage format
- Candidate-focused story; separate story about a councillor’s concerns
- Candidates named
- Nate Morris; Christopher Cummings; Peter McKenna
Story A — candidate-focused story about Nate Morris
Front-page headline
“Electing Morris could cost town a million dollars”
Print page 1 · Combined PDF page 101Article headline
“Electing Nathaniel Morris could cost the Town a million dollars”
Print page 3 · Combined PDF page 103Story B — separate story about councillor Stephen Robinson’s concerns
Article headline
“Candidate raises concerns over Strong Mayor Powers”
Print page 3 · Combined PDF page 103This is a separate story about councillor Stephen Robinson’s concerns. It discusses Morris but is not a second Morris candidate profile.
- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- No
Issue 7 of 10
October 7, 2026
- Coverage format
- Separate candidate profiles
- Candidates with separate profiles in the selected coverage
- Peter McKenna; Christopher Cummings
Peter McKenna profile
Article headline
“McKenna campaigns on experience, planning and our community-first”
Print page 10 · Combined PDF page 130Christopher Cummings profile
Article headline
“Cummings pitches experience, financial background as asset”
Print page 11 · Combined PDF page 131The selected coverage in this issue includes separate profiles for McKenna and Cummings. Morris is named as a competing candidate but does not have a separate profile in this issue.
- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- Yes
Issue 8 of 10
October 14, 2026
- Coverage format
- Shared all-candidates meeting report, with candidate-specific sections
- Candidates named
- Peter McKenna; Nate Morris; Christopher Cummings
Shared report with candidate-specific sections
Front-page headline
“Candidates offer their visions for future of town”
Print page 1 · Combined PDF page 141Shared article headline
“Three mayoral candidates offer contrasting visions for town at packed election meeting”
Print page 2 · Combined PDF page 142Peter McKenna section heading
“Peter McKenna emphasizes his experience and stability”
Print page 2 · Combined PDF page 142Nate Morris section heading
“Nate Morris campaigns on accountability and change”
Print page 3 · Combined PDF page 143Christopher Cummings section heading
“Cummings offers experience with a willingness to change”
Print page 3 · Combined PDF page 143- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- Yes
Issue 9 of 10
October 21, 2026
- Coverage format
- Separate candidate profiles
- Candidates named
- Christopher Cummings; Nate Morris; Peter McKenna
Christopher Cummings profile
Article headline
“Cummings pitches experience and financial leadership”
Print page 9 · Combined PDF page 169Nate Morris profile
Article headline
“Morris campaigns on accountability, affordability and a dismissal of CAO”
Print page 10 · Combined PDF page 170Peter McKenna profile
Secondary display line
“Plus collaboration and a community-first approach”
Print page 11 · Combined PDF page 171- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- No
Issue 10 of 10
October 28, 2026
- Coverage format
- Election results; newly elected mayor profile
- Candidates named
- Christopher Cummings; Peter McKenna; Nate Morris
Story A — profile of the newly elected mayor
Story B — election results
Mayor results as printed
- Chris Cummings — 1,781
- Peter McKenna — 986
- Nathaniel Morris — 599
- Full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in this issue
- Yes
Municipal Advertising Material
The ten consecutive issues in this sample, covering the Smiths Falls municipal election, include full-page Town of Smiths Falls content in eight issues. These pages combine formal public notices and election information with service updates, program announcements and event promotions. The two Veterans Way street-renaming notices were required to appear in a local newspaper under the Town’s Street Naming By-law, but the required notices did not need to occupy a full page. Election law required certain voting information to be provided, but did not prescribe newspaper publication. The vast majority of the space across these pages was devoted to discretionary municipal content. The combined PDF records what appeared in the issues; its inclusion does not establish a connection between Town content and editorial coverage.
Comments and questions
Reviewers who want to share comments or ask questions can write to info@valleyjournalismproject.ca.
